Thanksgiving Madness

Pick the Best Feast!

Welcome to the Cleveland Hot List Thanksgiving Madness! Here's how it works: 16 nominees will face o

… show more
Round 1 Ended
Round 2 Ended
Semis & Finals Ended
Round 2 Ended
Round 1 Ended
  • 753 Total Votes
  • 1 Winner

Rnd 1

Voting in Round 1 is over.
Pier W, Great Meals, Brunch, Seafood, Romantic Restaurant, 12700 Lake Avenue Lakewood OH 44107 Pier W
Round 1
Nov 20 - Nov 21
Pier W, Great Meals, Brunch, Seafood, Romantic Restaurant, 12700 Lake Avenue Lakewood OH 44107
Pier W Lakewood 81.1%
Rider's Inn, Great Meals, Romantic Restaurant, New American, 792 Mentor Ave Painesville OH 44077
Rider's Inn Painesville 18.9%
View this match
Round 1
Nov 20 - Nov 21
The Cabin of Willowick, Great Meals, New American, 28810 Lake Shore Blvd. Willowick OH 44095
The Cabin of Willowick Willowick 30.6%
Bistro 185, Great Meals, New American, Traditional American, 991 East 185th Street North Shores Cleveland OH 44119
Bistro 185 North Shores 69.4%
View this match
Round 1
Nov 20 - Nov 21
Lodge at Geneva State Park, Great Meals, New American, 4888 North Broadway Geneva-on-the-Lake OH 44041
Lodge at Geneva State Park Geneva-on-the-Lake 20.0%
LockKeepers, Great Meals, New American, Traditional American, 8001 Old Rockside Rd Valley View OH 44125
LockKeepers Valley View 80.0%
View this match
Round 1
Nov 20 - Nov 21
Don's Pomeroy House, Great Meals, New American, Seafood, Steakhouse, 13664 Pearl Rd Strongsville OH 44136
Don's Pomeroy House Strongsville 65.9%
Mapleside Farms, Weddings, Great Meals, Shopping, Specialty Food and Drink, Caterer, Brunch, Gift Shop, Bakery, Venue, Family Restaurant, Romantic Restaurant, 294 Pearl Road Brunswick OH 44212
Mapleside Farms Brunswick 34.1%
View this match
Round 1
Nov 20 - Nov 21
Papa Joe's Iacomini's, Great Meals, Italian, Romantic Restaurant, Family Restaurant, 1561 Akron Peninsula Road Akron OH
Papa Joe's Iacomini's Akron 33.3%
Harry's Steak House, Great Meals, Steakhouse, Traditional American, 5664 Brecksville Rd Independence OH 44131
Harry's Steak House Independence 66.7%
View this match
Round 1
Nov 20 - Nov 21
Blue Canyon Kitchen and Tavern, Great Meals, Comfort Food, Traditional American, New American, Romantic Restaurant, Seafood, Steakhouse, Brunch, 8960 Wilcox Drive Twinsburg OH 44087
Blue Canyon Kitchen and Tavern Twinsburg 50.0%
100th Bomb Group Restaurant, Great Meals, Comfort Food, Traditional American, Brunch, Romantic Restaurant, 20920 Brookpark Road Riverside Cleveland OH 44135
100th Bomb Group Restaurant Riverside 50.0%
View this match
Round 1
Nov 20 - Nov 21
Parallax Restaurant, Great Meals, Sushi, Seafood, Mediterranean, 2179 W. Eleventh St. Tremont Cleveland OH 44113
Parallax Restaurant Tremont 50.0%
Gamekeeper's Taverne, Great Meals, New American, Traditional American, 87 West Street Chagrin Falls OH 44022
Gamekeeper's Taverne Chagrin Falls 50.0%
View this match
Round 1
Nov 20 - Nov 21
Mallorca Restaurant, Great Meals, Seafood, 1390 West 9th Street Downtown Cleveland OH 44113
Mallorca Restaurant Downtown 69.3%
Shula's 2 Steak & Sports, Great Meals, Steakhouse, 6200 Quarry Lane Independence OH 44131
Shula's 2 Steak & Sports Independence 30.7%
View this match

Rnd 2

Voting in Round 2 is over.
Pier W, Great Meals, Brunch, Seafood, Romantic Restaurant, 12700 Lake Avenue Lakewood OH 44107 Pier W
Round 2
Nov 21 - Nov 23
Pier W, Great Meals, Brunch, Seafood, Romantic Restaurant, 12700 Lake Avenue Lakewood OH 44107
Pier W Lakewood 86.7%
Bistro 185, Great Meals, New American, Traditional American, 991 East 185th Street North Shores Cleveland OH 44119
Bistro 185 North Shores 13.3%
View this match
Round 2
Nov 21 - Nov 23
LockKeepers, Great Meals, New American, Traditional American, 8001 Old Rockside Rd Valley View OH 44125
LockKeepers Valley View 76.9%
Don's Pomeroy House, Great Meals, New American, Seafood, Steakhouse, 13664 Pearl Rd Strongsville OH 44136
Don's Pomeroy House Strongsville 23.1%
View this match
Round 2
Nov 21 - Nov 23
Harry's Steak House, Great Meals, Steakhouse, Traditional American, 5664 Brecksville Rd Independence OH 44131
Harry's Steak House Independence 50.0%
Blue Canyon Kitchen and Tavern, Great Meals, Comfort Food, Traditional American, New American, Romantic Restaurant, Seafood, Steakhouse, Brunch, 8960 Wilcox Drive Twinsburg OH 44087
Blue Canyon Kitchen and Tavern Twinsburg 50.0%
View this match
Round 2
Nov 21 - Nov 23
Parallax Restaurant, Great Meals, Sushi, Seafood, Mediterranean, 2179 W. Eleventh St. Tremont Cleveland OH 44113
Parallax Restaurant Tremont 33.3%
Mallorca Restaurant, Great Meals, Seafood, 1390 West 9th Street Downtown Cleveland OH 44113
Mallorca Restaurant Downtown 66.7%
View this match

Rnd 3

Voting in Round 3 is over.
Pier W, Great Meals, Brunch, Seafood, Romantic Restaurant, 12700 Lake Avenue Lakewood OH 44107 Pier W
Round 3
Nov 23 - Nov 25
Pier W, Great Meals, Brunch, Seafood, Romantic Restaurant, 12700 Lake Avenue Lakewood OH 44107
Pier W Lakewood 100%
LockKeepers, Great Meals, New American, Traditional American, 8001 Old Rockside Rd Valley View OH 44125
LockKeepers Valley View 0%
View this match
Round 3
Nov 23 - Nov 25
Blue Canyon Kitchen and Tavern, Great Meals, Comfort Food, Traditional American, New American, Romantic Restaurant, Seafood, Steakhouse, Brunch, 8960 Wilcox Drive Twinsburg OH 44087
Blue Canyon Kitchen and Tavern Twinsburg 0%
Mallorca Restaurant, Great Meals, Seafood, 1390 West 9th Street Downtown Cleveland OH 44113
Mallorca Restaurant Downtown 100%
View this match

Rnd 4

Voting in Round 4 is over.
Pier W, Great Meals, Brunch, Seafood, Romantic Restaurant, 12700 Lake Avenue Lakewood OH 44107 Pier W
Round 4
Nov 25 - Nov 27
Pier W, Great Meals, Brunch, Seafood, Romantic Restaurant, 12700 Lake Avenue Lakewood OH 44107
Pier W Lakewood 100%
Mallorca Restaurant, Great Meals, Seafood, 1390 West 9th Street Downtown Cleveland OH 44113
Mallorca Restaurant Downtown 0%
View this match

Bracket Nominees

  • Lodge at Geneva State Park, Great Meals, New American, 4888 North Broadway Geneva-on-the-Lake OH 44041 Lodge at Geneva State Park Geneva-on-the-Lake
  • Mapleside Farms, Weddings, Great Meals, Shopping, Specialty Food and Drink, Caterer, Brunch, Gift Shop, Bakery, Venue, Family Restaurant, Romantic Restaurant, 294 Pearl Road Brunswick OH 44212 Mapleside Farms Brunswick "Please take a second if you can and vote for Mapleside Farms for Fox 8 Akron-Canton Hotlist! Every vote will help..."
  • The Cabin of Willowick, Great Meals, New American, 28810 Lake Shore Blvd. Willowick OH 44095 The Cabin of Willowick Willowick
  • Gamekeeper's Taverne, Great Meals, New American, Traditional American, 87 West Street Chagrin Falls OH 44022 Gamekeeper's Taverne Chagrin Falls "Chagrin Falls is the perfect place to go out (in any season) for a great meal. Gamekeeper's is a "don't miss" in..."
  • Shula's 2 Steak & Sports, Great Meals, Steakhouse, 6200 Quarry Lane Independence OH 44131 Shula's 2 Steak & Sports Independence "In my book, you are #1. Best steak I have ever had hands down! You won't be disappointed...just give it a try."
  • LockKeepers, Great Meals, New American, Traditional American, 8001 Old Rockside Rd Valley View OH 44125 LockKeepers Valley View "Dante's is the best restaurant I have ever eaten at. I've been to several Emeril's locations. I've also been to Paula..."
  • Bistro 185, Great Meals, New American, Traditional American, 991 East 185th Street North Shores Cleveland OH 44119 Bistro 185 North Shores "Dining out at Bistro 185 always is amazing!! You never walk away hungry and the quality of food selections is..."
  • Rider's Inn, Great Meals, Romantic Restaurant, New American, 792 Mentor Ave Painesville OH 44077 Rider's Inn Painesville "My family away from home!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Rays Garlic wings and banna's foster saves my marriage!!! Karen Karen..."
  • Blue Canyon Kitchen and Tavern, Great Meals, Comfort Food, Traditional American, New American, Romantic Restaurant, Seafood, Steakhouse, Brunch, 8960 Wilcox Drive Twinsburg OH 44087 Blue Canyon Kitchen and Tavern Twinsburg "This is one our favorite restuarants'. We are members of their Horseshoe Club. Whenever we have friends visiting..."
  • Mallorca Restaurant, Great Meals, Seafood, 1390 West 9th Street Downtown Cleveland OH 44113 Mallorca Restaurant Downtown "Mallorca has it all, urban chic, great seafood, professional service from a classy staff. You feel at home from the..."
  • Harry's Steak House, Great Meals, Steakhouse, Traditional American, 5664 Brecksville Rd Independence OH 44131 Harry's Steak House Independence "Many may not know about Harrys Steakhouse. Its on Rt.21 across the street from Cloverleaf Bowling Alley in Independence..."
  • Parallax Restaurant, Great Meals, Sushi, Seafood, Mediterranean, 2179 W. Eleventh St. Tremont Cleveland OH 44113 Parallax Restaurant Tremont "I started coming to Parallax for their sushi. I still go once a week, but I have graduated to their other foods now..."
  • Don's Pomeroy House, Great Meals, New American, Seafood, Steakhouse, 13664 Pearl Rd Strongsville OH 44136 Don's Pomeroy House Strongsville "Just voted-from your friends at The Cute Little Cake Shop in Strongsville! Best of luck!!! We would love your votes..."
  • 100th Bomb Group Restaurant, Great Meals, Comfort Food, Traditional American, Brunch, Romantic Restaurant, 20920 Brookpark Road Riverside Cleveland OH 44135 100th Bomb Group Restaurant Riverside "My family, including myself, absolutely love the 100th Bomb Group for Sunday brunch. Huge selection and delicious food..."
  • Papa Joe's Iacomini's, Great Meals, Italian, Romantic Restaurant, Family Restaurant, 1561 Akron Peninsula Road Akron OH Papa Joe's Iacomini's Akron "People have the mistaken idea that The Olive Garden or The Macaroni Grille offer authentic Italian food. Nothing could..."
  • Pier W, Great Meals, Brunch, Seafood, Romantic Restaurant, 12700 Lake Avenue Lakewood OH 44107 Pier W Lakewood "Good brunch but this place should be listed under the Best Romantic Restaurant. It is nationally known and..."
Sections
Arts and Entertainment
Auto
Beauty & Wellness
Cheap Eats
Fashion
Fitness
Great Meals
Local Flavor
Nightlife
Pets
Shopping
Specialty Food and Drink
Weddings
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
Thanksgiving Madness
Microbrew Madness
Sitemap
Information
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
About
The Cleveland Hot List features more than 6,663 businesses competing for title of Cleveland's best.

Connect with Cleveland Hot List

@CleHotList